What Goes In A Seafood Boil

What Goes In A Seafood Boil

What Goes In A Seafood Boil

Are you curious about seafood boils? They're a fun and tasty way to enjoy seafood. A seafood boil is like a big pot of yummy sea creatures. People love them because they're easy to make and fun to eat with friends. 

In this article, we'll talk about what goes into a seafood boil. You'll learn about the different types of seafood and other ingredients that make it so good.

Get ready to learn about this delicious meal!

Seafood Stars

Unsurprisingly, the seafood itself is at the heart of any great seafood boil. The beauty of this dish is its versatility.

You can mix and match various types of seafood to create your perfect combination. Let's dive into some of the most popular options:

Shellfish: The Crowd Pleasers

Shellfish form the backbone of most seafood boils, offering a range of textures and flavours that delight the palate. Here are some favourites:


  • Shrimp: These quick-cooking crustaceans are a staple in most boils. Opt for large or jumbo shrimp with the shells on for maximum flavour.
  • Crab: From sweet blue crabs to meaty Dungeness, crab adds a luxurious touch to your boil. Snow crab legs are another popular choice, offering sweet meat that's easy to extract.
  • Crawfish: Essential in Cajun-style boils, these small freshwater crustaceans pack a flavorful punch. They're typically used when in season, usually from late winter to early summer.
  • Lobster: While less common in traditional boils, lobster tails or whole lobsters can add a decadent twist to your feast.

Fish Options: A Taste of the Sea

While less common than shellfish, fish can be a delicious addition to your seafood boil.

Whole fish like red snapper or sea bass can be added for variety, while firm white fish fillets such as cod or halibut can be included with careful timing to prevent overcooking.

Molluscs: Shells of Delight

Molluscs bring their unique flavours to the boil. Clams, mussels, and occasionally oysters can be added to the mix, each contributing its briny essence to the overall flavour profile.

Essential Vegetables and Starches:

No seafood boil is complete without a supporting cast of vegetables and starches. These ingredients bulk up the meal and soak up the flavorful broth, becoming delicious in their own right.

Corn on the cob is a non-negotiable addition to most seafood boils. Cut into 2-3 inch pieces, these golden nuggets become infused with the seasoned broth, offering sweet pops of flavour between bites of seafood.

Potatoes are crucial for soaking up the rich, spicy broth. Red potatoes, baby potatoes, or fingerling potatoes are excellent choices, each offering a slightly different texture and flavour. For best results, consider par-boiling larger potatoes before adding them to the seafood boil to ensure even cooking.

Onions and garlic form an aromatic base for the boil. Whole small or quartered large onions add sweetness and depth to the broth, while whole garlic cloves, with their papery skins left on, become mellow and spreadable during cooking.

Other popular vegetable additions include:


  • Mushrooms (button or cremini)
  • Carrots
  • Celery

These vegetables add nutrition and contribute to the complex flavour profile of the boil.

Flavorful Additions:

To take your seafood boil to the next level, consider these flavorful additions:

Sausage might seem like an unconventional addition to seafood, but it's a time-honoured tradition in many regions. Andouille sausage, with its spicy and smoky flavour, is a popular choice in Cajun-style boils.

For a milder option, consider kielbasa or add chorizo for a Spanish twist.

Citrus and herbs bring bright notes to the rich flavours of the boil. Lemon wedges can be squeezed over the finished boil or cooked in the broth for a citrusy kick.

Bay leaves add depth and complexity to the broth, while fresh herbs like thyme, parsley, or cilantro can be added at the end for a fresh finish.

Boil Seasonings:

The seasoning transforms a pot of boiled seafood into a memorable feast. While pre-made spice blends like Crabby Bags seasoning, Old Bay Seasoning or Zatarain's Crab Boil are convenient, creating your mix allows for customization. If you are new to creating your own seafood boil sauce try out our Original and Cajun Seasoning mixes! Both are great on all things seafood and it will help that the hard work out of making sure your seafood boil taste good. 

Here's a basic recipe to start with:


  • 1/4 cup paprika
  • Two tablespoons each of garlic powder, onion powder, dried oregano, and dried thyme
  • One tablespoon each of black pepper, white pepper, and cayenne pepper
  • Two tablespoons salt

Feel free to adjust the heat level and salt to your preference. Bold flavours are the key to a great boil, so don't be shy about seasoning!

Regional variations add their flair to the seasoning mix. Cajun-style boils often include extra cayenne pepper and garlic, while New England boils might feature more herbs like dill.

West Coast variations sometimes incorporate Asian influences with ginger and lemongrass.

Liquid Base:

The liquid in which you boil your seafood and vegetables is crucial for infusing flavour throughout the dish. Water is the most basic option, allowing the seasonings to shine.

Consider using beer (light lagers work well) or stock (seafood or vegetable) for added depth.

A good rule of thumb is to use about 1/4 cup of seasoning mix per quart of liquid for a well-balanced flavour.

Serving Accompaniments: The Final Touch

To complete your seafood boil experience, offer these accompaniments:

Or skip all of the hard work and simple order the Crabby Bags Seafood butter sauce! All you need to do is heat it up and add it to your seafood boil.


  • Melted butter
  • Cocktail sauce
  • Lemon wedges
  • Hot sauce options (such as Tabasco, Crystal, or Sriracha)

These additions allow your guests to customize their seafood experience to their liking.

Tips for a Successful Seafood Boil

Creating a perfect seafood boil requires attention to detail and timing. Here are some key tips to ensure your boil is a success:

  1. Follow the right cooking order:
    • Start with ingredients that take the longest to cook (potatoes, corn, onions)
    • Add sausage next
    • Follow with seafood in order of cooking time (crab, lobster, then shrimp and mussels)
  2. Season properly:
    • Season the water generously before adding any ingredients
    • Taste the broth and adjust the seasoning before adding seafood
  3. Serve with style:
    • Drain the boil or serve with slotted spoons to prevent sogginess
    • Spread newspapers or butcher paper on the table for easy cleanup
    • Provide plenty of napkins, wet wipes, and crackers for shellfish
  4. Prioritize safety:
    • Ensure all seafood is cooked to safe internal temperatures
    • Discard any shellfish that don't open during cooking
    • Refrigerate leftovers promptly and consume within 1-2 days

Conclusion: Your Seafood Boil Adventure Awaits

A seafood boil is more than just a meal – an event, a celebration of flavours and textures that unite people. With this guide, you can create your spectacular seafood boil, whether sticking to tradition or putting your unique spin on this beloved dish.

Remember, the beauty of a seafood boil lies in its flexibility. Feel free to experiment with different combinations of seafood, vegetables, and seasonings. The possibilities are as vast as the ocean itself!

Shop the story